This week, on Tuesday, 8/26/10, in New York City, in a shameful display of stupidity, a drunk, 21 year old man stabbed a Muslim cab driver - apparently just for being a Muslim. This is probably the definition of a hate crime. Some are already jumping to conclusions about the incident, saying it was related to the Cordoba House Mosque building project near Ground Zero. Perhaps, but probably not in the way you might think. Turns out the drunk worked with an organization that apparently favors the project, and the Muslim cab driver opposes the project. So perhaps the attack was about eliminating the opposition, in this case a reformist or moderate Muslim who was against the building project. In today's Wall Street Journal, Ms. Irshad Manji is also a Reformist Muslim who is opposed to the Cordoba House expansion project. You can read her thoughts here. She has a list of questions we should be asking. I hope we get some answers.
9 years ago, in the aftermath of September 11, as one could imagine, there was indeed a spike in crimes against Muslims.
National Review: According to the FBI, hate crimes against Muslims increased by a
staggering 1,600 percent in 2001. That sounds serious! But wait, the
increase is a math mirage. There were 28 anti-Islamic incidents in 2000.
That number climbed to 481 the year a bunch of Muslim terrorists
murdered 3,000 Americans in the name of Islam on Sept. 11.
....The following year, the number of anti-Islamic hate-crime incidents
(overwhelmingly, nonviolent vandalism and nasty words) dropped to 155.
In 2003, there were 149 such incidents. And the number has hovered
around the mid-100s or lower ever since.
What about hate crimes against Jews?
National Review: In 2001, there were twice as many anti-Jewish incidents as there were
anti-Muslim, according to the FBI. In 2002 and pretty much every year
since, anti-Jewish incidents have outstripped anti-Muslim incidents by
at least 6 to 1.
Six to one!! According to FBI statistics on hate crimes for 2008, 65% of the so-called hate crimes were pronounced 'Anti-Jewish' while 7.7% were labeled 'Anti-Muslim'.
So do we have an Anti-Muslim climate or an Anti-Jewish climate? No one really wants to discuss these facts.
What about hate crimes against Christians?
Again, according to FBI statistics on hate crimes for 2008, when you add up the raw numbers and percentages, there were slightly more hate crimes committed against Christians, both Protestant and Catholic, than there were against Muslims.
On certain news programs and on numerous Internet sites, open hatred toward right wing (evangelical) Christians is all the rage. It seems perfectly acceptable to openly criticize those who have a different view as long as they are right wing (evangelical) Christians.
So, in order, here you have it - for 2008:
- Anti-Jewish hate crimes 65%
- Anti-Christian hate crimes 8.4%
- Anti-Muslim hate crimes 7.7%
The bottom line?
Things are not always as they seem folks. If we are all to get along, we must stop calling each other names, we must begin to accept each others differences without being forced to advocate these differences.
How about we build an international, multi-faith worship center next to Ground Zero that would allow people of all faiths, spiritual but not religious, or no faith; to come and reflect, worship, meditate and contemplate on their terms as we learn to respect and love our neighbors without fear of religious intimidation?